Tarleton State University Athletics Hall of Fame
All-Conference honoree in 1985, 1986 and 1987 for volleyball. She was named the team's MVP and selected to the all-district team in 1987. Caldwell received the Most Inspirational Award all four of her seasons in volleyball. In tennis, she was a member of the Texas Intercollegiate Athletics Association conference championship doubles team in 1988 and MVP in 1987. The TexAnn Award for Leadership was also given to Caldwell the same year.